A real estate appraisal can affect major financial decisions, such as buying a home or securing a loan. If an appraiser makes a serious error, California law may allow you to sue for negligence if you relied on the report and suffered a financial loss.
When does an appraiser owe you a duty of care?
An appraiser may owe a duty to someone beyond the person who hired them if they knew that person would receive and rely on the appraisal. California courts consider the appraisal’s intended use and the people the appraiser expected to rely on it.
Who can bring a claim against a real estate appraiser?
You may have grounds to bring a claim if the appraiser’s work caused you a financial loss and you fall into one of these groups:
- The person who hired the appraiser: You may have a claim if the appraiser failed to provide the agreed services with reasonable care.
- A lender or investor: You may have a claim if the appraiser knew you or a specific group you belong to would rely on the appraisal when making a financial decision.
- An intended third-party beneficiary: You may have a claim if the appraisal agreement was expressly made for your benefit.
In Soderberg v. McKinney (1996), the court allowed investors to sue because the appraiser knew they would rely on the report. Your claim depends on the circumstances and your losses.
What should you do about a negligent appraisal?
Keep a copy of the appraisal report, loan documents, purchase records and any messages about the valuation. You can also get an independent appraisal to check the property’s value. These records may help show where the original report went wrong and how the error affected your finances.
Protect your rights after an appraisal error
A faulty appraisal can lead to serious financial problems, but you may have options. Review the report, keep records of your losses and speak with a California professional malpractice attorney. An attorney can assess your situation, explain your legal options and help you decide what to do next.